This was a beautiful documentary. The way it was shot was enchanting, the way the girls spoke, with such passion for learning and school was heart breaking. But something nagged at me. I felt a little sickness creep into my stomach that didn't let off.. It is so difficult to raise a voice that you know will be met with argument and shock, but I can't help it.
I think of the documentary "Schooling the World" introduced to me by my advisor Dr. Yellow Bird and I become so sad.
What is the answer to the issue of poverty and suffering? If western colonist agendas like spreading western education throughout the world and thus creating a new generation that doesn't speak or read in their native language are not the answer, how do we raise our voices to add to the ideas behind these documentaries? It feels strange to have learned about this issue of education through education which makes my head spin. Without my western education, I wouldn't know about the awful and horrible consequences of blindly forcing children into boarding schools and educating them out of their cultural heritage. It feels sickening to raise a voice AGAINST a documentary and idea that seem so beautiful, so innocent and good hearted. But then I think if they are so good hearted, they should welcome debate and new/conflicting ideas into the dialogue.
I think of the documentary "Schooling the World" introduced to me by my advisor Dr. Yellow Bird and I become so sad.
What is the answer to the issue of poverty and suffering? If western colonist agendas like spreading western education throughout the world and thus creating a new generation that doesn't speak or read in their native language are not the answer, how do we raise our voices to add to the ideas behind these documentaries? It feels strange to have learned about this issue of education through education which makes my head spin. Without my western education, I wouldn't know about the awful and horrible consequences of blindly forcing children into boarding schools and educating them out of their cultural heritage. It feels sickening to raise a voice AGAINST a documentary and idea that seem so beautiful, so innocent and good hearted. But then I think if they are so good hearted, they should welcome debate and new/conflicting ideas into the dialogue.
It seems we are creating a world where the only way we see of getting ahead is through this western machine called education. This is not a new concept because western culture did this to Native Americans and indigenous people throughout the colonized world. They would look at the indigenous culture and say "oh if we don't educate this little girl, she will get married young and remain a SAVAGE". Saying western education is the answer is making a huge value choice. I am not saying it is the wrong one, certain cultural norms are disturbing like Female Genital Mutiliation, FGM, etc but still we are always making a value choice based on our beliefs and imposing them upon others. Some things I feel strongly about like genocide and I believe the international community needs to step in and prevent genocide, FGM, violence against any person. But when it comes to education, it is harder to decipher what is colonization and basically devaluing another culture in hopes they will "develop" into a more westernized, "modern" state or if education is the tool for women's global empowerment. It is so confusing. So many times the good things done around the world have ulterior motives. Take the movie Rabbit Proof Fence for example. Sure they were trying to prevent a child marriage but there was so much more going on as an ulterior motive.
When I look at my own choices and privilege in life, I notice that I too felt and feel like without my education I wouldn't have had a viable future. But then am I propagating a system that forces people like myself to feel this way? Am I part of the never ending problem? It is impossible for me to know because I am myself and I can't separate out my own feelings from the larger picture. While it may be true that education is the key to monetary success and some disease prevention, are we not creating this reality ourselves through making it so education is a requirement of it? Didn't colonialism CREATE poverty and injustice around the world by conquering people and forcing them to culturally assimilate? What were these places like before they were colonized? When I look at myself, I can't help but feel like my view is so skewed by my own colonization and mental limitations.
I would love to think there is just one answer for world peace like veganism, if everyone followed some religion or if all people were "educated", etc. I don't want anyone to starve, I want everyone to be free and happy and honestly I would sacrifice a lot personally for this to happen but how? When I think about what I could do, I find that I don't think that modeling the world after the US, who does educate each child, is the answer to everything. The US creates wars and kills millions, people live in poverty here.. especially if you are Native American or a person of color.
I am starting to realize that the ways in which I try to "educate" myself like watching documentaries are not necessary windows into the reality of any given situation. I will always be ignorant of the real situation of any one's life until I go and walk a mile in their moccasins or just listen to what they truly have to say. Are we all not burdened by our own fears and biases? I remain wary of education and what education even means. Just because statistics show that with more education, a person waits longer to have children, has less of a chance to contract HIV does not necessarily mean education is the CAUSE nor does it mean westernized education is the only way to get that result.
When I look at my own choices and privilege in life, I notice that I too felt and feel like without my education I wouldn't have had a viable future. But then am I propagating a system that forces people like myself to feel this way? Am I part of the never ending problem? It is impossible for me to know because I am myself and I can't separate out my own feelings from the larger picture. While it may be true that education is the key to monetary success and some disease prevention, are we not creating this reality ourselves through making it so education is a requirement of it? Didn't colonialism CREATE poverty and injustice around the world by conquering people and forcing them to culturally assimilate? What were these places like before they were colonized? When I look at myself, I can't help but feel like my view is so skewed by my own colonization and mental limitations.
I would love to think there is just one answer for world peace like veganism, if everyone followed some religion or if all people were "educated", etc. I don't want anyone to starve, I want everyone to be free and happy and honestly I would sacrifice a lot personally for this to happen but how? When I think about what I could do, I find that I don't think that modeling the world after the US, who does educate each child, is the answer to everything. The US creates wars and kills millions, people live in poverty here.. especially if you are Native American or a person of color.
I am starting to realize that the ways in which I try to "educate" myself like watching documentaries are not necessary windows into the reality of any given situation. I will always be ignorant of the real situation of any one's life until I go and walk a mile in their moccasins or just listen to what they truly have to say. Are we all not burdened by our own fears and biases? I remain wary of education and what education even means. Just because statistics show that with more education, a person waits longer to have children, has less of a chance to contract HIV does not necessarily mean education is the CAUSE nor does it mean westernized education is the only way to get that result.
Everything is an opinion, even what I am writing. I am sure 100 million people would gladly argue with me and tell me I am ignorant. Of course I am! We are limited to only know what one person could know, we only ever experience our own perceptions... we are horribly limited and biased. It is all just a ride, a game, an illusion. On this ride, for whatever reason, I chose to be a social activist and MSW student. I am starting to realize more and more that we cannot dismantle the master's house with the master's tools. Education is beautiful, so is fetching water. The real thing that matters is if the person is happy, if they are free to make choices in their life. Any way we can facilitate that is great, but suffering over the suffering will not solve any one's problems.
I mean obviously through domination of the media and being the colonizing world power, western culture looks appealing and looks like you would need to join in or you'll get left behind.. Maybe at this point in history it is true, if you don't learn English in Bangalore, you won't be able to find a decent job and you will go hungry. So do we then focus on getting everyone on board? What about fighting against the idea of needing to get "on board" in the first place? Why not fight against the idea of money, the idea of capitalism and how it creates poverty, the idea of war over distribution of resources? If those ideas changed, maybe the definition of education could be more free.
I am not against education per se or little girls around the world being educated. I am just hoping for dialogue about creating a broader definition of what education truly means. I hope to fight against the system itself that makes people starve if they aren't educated but that doesn't mean I don't believe in people being empowered through learning how to read and learning about history -- as long as they hear about more than just the west's version of history. I have the same worry as Howard Zinn when he spoke about his fears of the American youth:
After having seen many documentaries and read many books about the boarding school experience for Native Americans and the indigenous people of Australia, I am wary about "educating the world" and "no child left behind". We have suppressed so many indigenous voices that the education people receive is horribly limited. Learning how to read, write and calculate is necessary to "compete in the global market" but honestly many cultures survived without a written language and I don't feel like they were of less value then our "modern" society.
“I'm worried that students will take their obedient place in
society and look to become successful cogs in the wheel - let the wheel
spin them around as it wants without taking a look at what they're
doing. I'm concerned that students not become passive acceptors of the
official doctrine that's handed down to them from the White House, the
media, textbooks, teachers and preachers.”
― Howard Zinn
― Howard Zinn
After having seen many documentaries and read many books about the boarding school experience for Native Americans and the indigenous people of Australia, I am wary about "educating the world" and "no child left behind". We have suppressed so many indigenous voices that the education people receive is horribly limited. Learning how to read, write and calculate is necessary to "compete in the global market" but honestly many cultures survived without a written language and I don't feel like they were of less value then our "modern" society.
Over all I am not supporting any one side, just trying find the best way to support and love my fellow sisters and brothers through out the world.